Shoulder Instability
Traumatic shoulder instability refers to a condition where the shoulder joint (glenohumeral joint) becomes unstable following an injury or traumatic event. This instability occurs because the shoulder is forced out of its normal position, often leading to a dislocation (the humeral head slips out of the glenoid socket) or subluxation (partial dislocation where the humeral head moves but returns to its position). Traumatic shoulder instability is common in athletes and individuals involved in contact sports, but it can occur in anyone who sustains a significant shoulder injury. Patients may also experience multi-directional instability which is related to gross soft tissue laxity due to genetics, rather than an injury.
Anatomy Involved
​
The shoulder joint is a ball-and-socket joint, where the humeral head (ball) fits into the glenoid (socket) of the scapula (shoulder blade). Imagine a golf ball sitting on a golf tee. The shoulder has a wide range of motion but is inherently less stable due to its anatomy, making it susceptible to dislocation.
​
Key structures contributing to dynamic and static stability include:
​
• Labrum: A fibrocartilaginous ring around the glenoid that deepens the socket.
​
• Capsule: A ligamentous structure that surrounds the joint.
​
• Ligaments: Key ligaments, like the inferior glenohumeral ligament (IGHL), contribute to stability.
​
• Rotator Cuff Muscles: Muscles and tendons that support and dynamically stabilize the shoulder.
Causes
Traumatic shoulder instability is usually caused by a significant injury or forceful movement, including:
​
• Direct trauma: A blow to the shoulder, such as during a car accident or a fall onto an outstretched arm.
​
• Sports injuries: Common in contact sports (like football, rugby) or sports involving overhead activities (like volleyball, basketball, or throwing sports).
​
• Overuse injuries: Repetitive overhead movements can weaken the stabilizing structures over time, leading to instability.
​
Multi-directional instability is often seen in patients with genetic hyper-elastic connective tissue conditions such as Ehlers-Danlos syndrome.
Types of Traumatic Shoulder Instability
1. Anterior Instability (most common):
​
• Occurs when the humeral head dislocates forward, out of the front of the glenoid.
​
• Typically results from a fall onto an outstretched arm or excessive external rotation and abduction.
​
• Often associated with a Bankart lesion (a tear of the labrum) or a Hill-Sachs lesion (a dent in the humeral head).
​
2. Posterior Instability:
​
• Less common, with the humeral head dislocating backward.
​
• Usually due to a fall onto an outstretched arm with the shoulder internally rotated, or a direct blow to the front of the shoulder.
​
• Associated with labral tears on the posterior side.
​
3. Multidirectional Instability (MDI):
​
• Instability in multiple directions, often without a specific traumatic event.
​
• More common in individuals with loose or hypermobile joints (e.g., Ehlers-Danlos syndrome).
Symptoms
• Pain: Sudden, severe pain during or immediately after the injury. Persistent pain may occur with repeated instability.
​
• Visible deformity: In cases of dislocation, the shoulder may appear visibly out of place.
​
• Loss of range of motion: Difficulty moving the shoulder, particularly during overhead activities or lifting.
​
• Weakness: A feeling of instability or weakness when using the shoulder.
​
• Clicking or popping: Sensation of catching or popping during movement due to labral tears or loose structures.
Diagnosis
Diagnosis is based on:
​
• History and physical examination: Includes assessing the mechanism of injury, examining range of motion, and performing specific tests (e.g., Apprehension Test, Relocation Test, Load-and-Shift Test).
​
• Imaging:
​
• X-rays: To evaluate dislocation, associated fractures, or bone defects.
​
• MRI or MR arthrogram: To identify soft tissue injuries like labral tears, ligament injuries, or Hill-Sachs lesions.
​
• CT scan: May be used to assess bone defects or glenoid morphology.
Treatment
Treatment for traumatic shoulder instability aims to restore stability, relieve pain, and prevent recurrent dislocations:
​
1. Non-surgical management (for first-time dislocations or mild cases):
​
• Reduction: Repositioning the dislocated shoulder back into the joint.
​
• Immobilization: Wearing a sling for a few weeks to allow healing of injured tissues.
​
• Physical therapy: Strengthening exercises to improve rotator cuff and scapular stability; focusing on restoring range of motion and reducing future instability risk.
​
• Activity modification: Avoiding high-risk activities that could lead to recurrent instability.
​
2. Surgical management (for recurrent dislocations, significant injuries, or athletes):
​
• Arthroscopic Bankart repair: Reattaching and stabilizing a torn labrum and ligaments to the glenoid.
​
• Latarjet procedure: Bone transfer surgery, where a piece of the scapula bone, called the coracoid, is moved to the front of the glenoid to increase stability, typically used for significant bone loss or recurrent dislocations.
​
• Capsular shift or plication: Tightening the joint capsule to reduce laxity.
​
• Remplissage: Filling the Hill-Sachs defect with the infraspinatus tendon to prevent future dislocations. This is performed arthroscopically, typically in conjunction with a labral repair
Rehabilitation
Rehabilitation plays a crucial role in recovery:
​
• Initial phase: Gentle range of motion exercises, pain control, and reducing inflammation.
​
• Strengthening phase: Focus on strengthening rotator cuff and scapular muscles.
​
• Functional phase: Progress to sport-specific or activity-specific exercises.
Prognosis
​
The prognosis for traumatic shoulder instability varies based on factors like age, activity level, and the extent of injury. Younger individuals and athletes, particularly those involved in contact sports, are at higher risk for recurrent instability. Early and appropriate management, whether non-surgical or surgical, improves outcomes and reduces the risk of long-term complications like arthritis.
Prevention
• Strengthening: Focus on strengthening the rotator cuff, scapular stabilizers, and shoulder girdle muscles.
​
• Proper technique: Use correct techniques in sports and activities, especially overhead movements.
​
• Protective gear: Consider using shoulder braces or protective equipment during high-risk activities.
​